CFOS for QuickBooks, coming January 2027See what you get
PAVINGCFOS-01
PAVING · CIVIL AND EARTHWORK · FIXED BY STEP 01

The lab sets your price weeks after you already billed it

Nothing gets produced until the job mix formula is approved, and nothing is fully priced until the cores come back. In between, you're booking revenue at a number that isn't settled.

WHY IT'S A PAVING PROBLEM

Most subs know their selling price the day the contract is signed. In paving, a lab sets the selling price after the next lift covers the work, from samples out of mats you can no longer touch. So WIP on agency paving is a forecast of a lab result. Holding it at full value is how a strong June turns into a confusing August.

WHAT IT COSTS

The size of it

A 95 to 97 percent pay factor on a $400,000 paving item is $12,000 to $20,000 of revenue that month-end WIP already booked as earned. It comes back out later with no offsetting cost entry, so it looks like the crews got worse.

OVERHEAD AT $1M to $5M
14%
CFOS target 13% for paving.
GROSS MARGIN AT $1M to $5M
20%
CFOS target 23% for paving.
NET PROFIT AT $1M to $5M
6%
CFOS target 10% for paving.

On agency work you place tonnage at an unknown selling price and find out weeks later what it was worth. The plant can't produce a ton for the project until the agency lab approves the job mix formula, and the agency owns that clock. After placement, acceptance depends on statistical pay factors by sublot: density cores, thickness, air voids, and ride smoothness. Deductions or bonuses apply once the reports come back. The progress estimate bills the placement at full contract value and adjusts later. So revenue and job cost go on the books at a price that's still open, sometimes across a month-end close.

WHAT TO DO

Three moves, in order

STEP 01
Hold a pay factor reserve on every agency job in WIP, set from your own core and smoothness history, so the month-end number already assumes the lab.
STEP 02
Log JMF submittal and approval dates on the job schedule, and give the GC that waiting time as a production constraint before it becomes your delay.
STEP 03
Reconcile lab reports to sublots every month and post the deduction against the item and the mat it came from, while the crew can still tell you what happened that day.
QUESTIONS

What paving owners ask

How to handle asphalt pay factor deductions on a WIP report?

Nothing gets produced until the job mix formula is approved, and nothing is fully priced until the cores come back. In between, you're booking revenue at a number that isn't settled.

What does it cost?

A 95 to 97 percent pay factor on a $400,000 paving item is $12,000 to $20,000 of revenue that month-end WIP already booked as earned. It comes back out later with no offsetting cost entry, so it looks like the crews got worse.

What do I do first?

Hold a pay factor reserve on every agency job in WIP, set from your own core and smoothness history, so the month-end number already assumes the lab.

What are paving contractors supposed to be making?

Paving has 20% gross margin, 14% overhead and 6% net profit before taxes at $1M to $5M. The all-trade average is 7%, so this trade is 1 point below it. The CFOS target is 10%.

Which part of the system fixes it?

The step is number 01, job cost structure. Seven cost categories and three levels of granularity, built so the estimate and the ledger use the same words. It comes from chapter 1 of CONTROL: C.F.O.S. Construction Financial Operating System.

OR HAVE IT HANDLED

Everything on this page is something you can install yourself, and CONTROL is the order to do it in. If you would rather buy the finished result, SPM The Construction CFO does this work for paving contractors as a service. It is a separate firm, Sulphur Prairie Management, LLC, led by the same author.

What a fractional CFO does for paving contractors

AUTHOR
Josh Luebker
JOSH LUEBKER
MASTER ELECTRICIAN · 150+ PROJECTS · $2.1B+ MANAGED

Wrote CONTROL, the 8 step system behind these figures. More about the author.

Updated

8 Steps 60 Days

CONTROL is the full system, written for commercial subcontractors from $1M to $100M. It's out now. 8 steps, 6 working templates, and the order they install in. $9.99 ebook, $24.99 paperback.