JOB COSTING
SOFTWARE VS.
CFO.
Software is a container. A CFO designs the structure the software runs on. The two are not competing — they are complementary. Most commercial subcontractors over $1M need both: construction-specific software (Josh recommends ControlQore at ~$100/month per $1M in revenue) and a construction-specific fractional CFO ($1,900–$2,900/month) to design and run the financial system the software lives in. Either one alone produces incomplete results.
The contractors who try to buy software instead of installing a system are the ones who end up with expensive software that still gives them bad data. The structure has to come first.
| FACTOR | JOB COSTING SOFTWARE | CONSTRUCTION-SPECIFIC CFO |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Stores and processes data based on what you input | Designs and runs the financial system the software lives in |
| Job cost structure | Holds the structure once you set it up | Designs the structure based on your trade and operations |
| Overhead calculation | Does not calculate — you must input the rate | Calculates real overhead and rebuilds bid templates |
| Estimating alignment | Stores cost codes that match estimates | Aligns estimating phases to job cost codes — the alignment meeting |
| Cost to complete | Generates the report if data is input | Interprets the report and identifies action items |
| Monthly CEO meeting | Cannot do | Runs the meeting — actionable to-dos, responsible party, due dates |
| 13-week cash forecast | Can output if configured | Builds it correctly the first time with construction-specific timing |
| Bonding & surety prep | Generates WIP reports | Optimizes WIP and working capital for bonding capacity |
| Decision support | None | Core function — every monthly meeting and every major decision |
| Annual cost | ~$100/mo per $1M revenue (ControlQore) | $1,900–$2,900/mo (fractional CFO) |
| Construction-specific | Yes (if you pick the right software) | Critical — generic CFOs miss WIP, retainage, pay-when-paid |
For most trade contractors: both. The question is which one to install first.
If you have no job cost structure today: start with the CFO. Get the structure designed first. Then install the software to hold it. Buying software first and asking it to figure out the structure for you is how contractors end up with expensive accounting platforms that still produce bad reports.
If you have a structure but it is broken or aging: a fractional CFO can rebuild it in 30 days while you continue running on your current software. Then migrate to ControlQore once the structure is right.
If you are over $5M and serious about growth: you need both, full stop. The decisions you are making at that revenue level require forward visibility (CFO) and real-time data (software) working together.
- You are doing $250K–$500K and just need a place to track job costs
- You have an existing CFO or controller designing the structure
- You are a pure GC who only manages subs — not self-performing — and need simple project accounting
- You are using software as a stopgap until you can hire a CFO in the next 6–12 months
- You have job costing software but the data does not make sense
- You do not know your real overhead, gross margin, or net profit by project
- You are making decisions about hiring, equipment, or bonding without forward visibility
- You have switched accounting software twice and still cannot get clean reports
- You are over $1M in revenue with no monthly financial review cadence
WANT IT INSTALLED FOR YOU?
The CONTROL book teaches you how to build the system yourself. The Construction CFO — Sulphur Prairie Management — builds and runs it for you. Same system, same outcomes. Different path to get there. From $1,900/month. 60-day onboarding. 24 trades served.
No. Software stores and processes data — it does not decide what data to capture, how to structure it, or what to do about the results. A CFO designs the financial system the software runs on. Without that structural decision, software gives you bad data faster.
Yes, for most commercial subcontractors over $1M. The software is the platform that runs the system. The CFO designs and runs the system. Together they produce financial visibility. Either one alone produces incomplete results.
ControlQore. It is the platform Sulphur Prairie Management uses with every client. Priced at approximately $100/month per $1M in revenue. Built specifically for construction — not adapted from a generic accounting platform. See the partner page for full details.
ControlQore is approximately $100/month per $1M in revenue. A construction-specific fractional CFO is $1,900–$2,900/month. Software alone is incomplete. CFO without software is also incomplete. Most contractors should budget for both together as the full financial system cost.
Yes — the templates from the resources page work without software. But maintaining the system over time becomes increasingly difficult without proper construction job costing software. Most clients eventually move to ControlQore because Excel cannot scale with the business.
STRUCTURE FIRST. SOFTWARE SECOND.
CONTROL teaches the structure. The Construction CFO installs it. ControlQore runs it. Get the book.
JOIN THE WAITLIST →